631-666-2229 Bay Shore // 631-617-5014 Islip
Coyle's Ice Cream
75 Howells Rd. Bay Shore, N.Y.
509 Main St. Islip, N.Y.
Coyle's Ice Cream Welcomes You
Your Neighborhood Ice Cream Parlor
Now carrying Non-dairy Vegan Ice Cream!
50'S STYLE ICE CREAM PARLOR
MakIing 60 flavors of ice cream since 1985.
Come share memories while sitting at our soda fountain enjoying a Brooklyn Egg Cream or Malt.
Share a sticky finger sundae in an old fashioned booth while listening to songs from the 50s & 60s
Gift cards
Call to order
631-666-2229
will send directly to any phone or email
Find us on Grubhub, Doordash, and uber eats
Coyle's
What We’re All About
Coyles was founded in 1985 and has grown to become the best quality ice cream on Long Island. All our ice cream is homemade on premises and our dairy products come straight from the dairy giving you the freshest, highest quality ingredients available anywhere. We understand that you have options when it comes to Ice Cream Parlors. At Coyle's we treat everyone like family and add to your experience with delicious ice cream, amazing staff and outstanding customer service.
Come by to experience the Coyle's Ice Cream "Difference" for yourself.
Hours
75 Howells Road
Bay Shore, N.Y.
Mon: 3:00pm - 9:00pm Tues-Thurs: 1:00pm - 9:30pm Friday: 1:00pm - 10:30pm Saturday: 12:00pm -10:30pm Sunday: 12:00pm - 9:00pm
509 Main Street
Islip, N.Y.
Mon 3:00pm - 9:00pm
Tues-Thurs 1:00pm - 9:30pm
Fri: 1:00 - 10:30pm
Sat: 12:00pm - 10:30pm
Sun: 12:00pm - 9:00pm
Our Products
What’s In Store
Fresh Homemade ice cream
Ultra Premium Blends
Are you a fan of classic favorites? Are you constantly craving something satisfying and delicious that will warm your soul? Our vast assortment of the creamiest flavors will have you on the train to flavortown in a matter of minutes. Flavors so good your tastebuds will thank you!
specialty and made to order cakes
Authentic Flavor
Are you constantly searching for something different for that special event? Look no further, because we have exactly what you need! At Coyle's Ice Cream we carry a large variety of products, including specialty and custom made cakes which will be sure to satisfy your guests and your taste buds! Wondering how you can get your hands on these tasty treats? Stop by to purchase it for yourself today!
ice cream sundaes and Assorted Toppings
All The Goodness
Take in all that we have to offer at Coyle's Ice Cream. We provide our customers with the best, most delicious, and of course, freshest products in the Bay Shore area. Our customers rave about our Sundaes and assorted toppings. If you’re curious as to why, stop by our store to experience it for yourself. We guarantee that once you do, you’ll soon understand what the buzz is all about.
Ice Cream sodas, shakes, floats, malts, and Egg Creams
Quality Goods
Our sodas and shakes are all made to order with any flavor or combination of flavors of our ultra premium ice cream your heart desires. Our old fashioned Brooklyn Egg Creams have been voted the best on Long Island! Yum Yum!!
Ice Cream Flavors
Vanilla _Vanilla Chip_Cookie Dough_Vanilla Fudge_Crazy Vanilla_Baileys Irish Cream
Vanilla Peanut Butter Fudge_Birthday Cake_Cake Batter_Maple Walnut-Butter Pecan
Mint Chocolate Chip_Mint Oreo_Peanut Butter Oreo_Heath Bar Crunch_Banana_Banana Oreo
Coffee_Moca Chip_Mississippi Mud_Pistachio Cherry_Pistachio Walnut_Oreo
Holy Canolli_Strawberry_ Strawberry Cheesecake_Raspberry_Apple Pie_Coconut_Cotton Candy
Rainbow Sherbert_Rum Raisin_Chocolate Espresso_Peanut Butter Fudge_Elvis Peanut Butter_Rocky Road_Monster Mash_Brownie Nut Fudge_Key Lime Pie_Smores Lu_Salted Caramel_Snickeroo
Chocolate Raspberry Chip_Chocolate Jelly Ring_Chocolate Oreo_Cherry Garcia_
Dulce De Leche_Nutella_Mama K's Peanut Butter & Jelly_Al's Dirty Banana
Seasonal Flavors Also Available
"Before Placing Your Order, Please Inform the Server If a Person in Your Party Has a Food Allergy"
Toppings
Add to any of our flavors to create your own Sundae
Wet Walnuts_Black Cherries_Red Cherries_Chocolate Syrup_Hot Fudge_Hot Caramel_Strawberries_Pineapples_Dry Peanuts_M&Ms_Reeses Pieces_Reeses Peanut Butter Cups_Marshmallow_Chocolate Sprinkles_Rainbow Sprinkles_Crunch_Butterscotch_Banana_Swedish Fish_Gummy Bears_Whipped Cream
Specialty Cakes
awesomeness awaits
Our specialty cakes and our regular vanilla/chocolate/crunch cakes are usually in stock for pick up any time.
You can custom order any size cake with up to three flavors of your choice, and with a choice of filling. Please alow 24 hours in placing this type of order.
size serves
mini 3-5
7" 5-8
8" 8-12
9" 12-15
10" 15-18
Sm. Sheet 20+
Lg. Sheet 40+
Oreo
Premium Oreo ice cream filled with crushed Oreo in a homemade Oreo crust.
Sticky Finger
Premium Vanilla ice cream blended with rich hot fudge crunch, broken pieces of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, and smooth creamy peanut butter.
Mississippi Mud
Premium coffee ice cream blended with crunch, Oreo cookies and fudge in a homemade Oreo crust.
Blend of the Best
Premium Oreo and chocolate raspberry ice cream filled with a layer of pound cake, chocolate chunks, and raspberry sauce in a homemade Oreo crust.
STRAWBERRY SHORTCAKE
Premium Strawberry and Vanilla ice cream layered with pound cake and Strawberry puree and topped with Strawberry topping.
Banana Split
20 of our most popular flavors together with a layer of sliced banana and crunch topped with hot fudge. Each layer will reveal a variety of flavors for you and your guests to enjoy.
Chocolate Raspberry
Premium chocolate raspberry ice cream filled with chocolate chunks and raspberry sauce in a homemade Oreo crust.
Chocolate Overload
Premium chocolate and Oreo ice cream filled with a layer of pound cake, chocolate chunks, and Belgian chocolate sauce in a homemade Oreo crust.
What’s In Store
Specialty Sundaes
Come inside our marvelous Ice Cream Parlor and see what the buzz is all about. We offer the largest variety of toppings and ice cream Sundaes on Long Island. Coyle's Ice Cream has changed the way you do dessert. Check out all of our specialty sundaes and get ready to enjoy the freshest, creamiest, and best tasting ice cream delights in town today!
Blackout of 65
Chocolate, Rocky Road, and Brownie Nut Fudge ice cream filled with Hot Fudge, Black Cherries and Crunch. Topped with whipped cream and a cherry!
Fire Islander
Mint Chip, Oreo Cookie, and Cherry Garcia ice cream filled with hot fudge, crunch, and marshmallow. Topped with whipped cream and a cherry!!
Brownie Fudge Sundae
Any two flavors of ice cream placed on top of warm fudge brownie, with hot fudge, whipped cream and a cherry!
Sticky Finger Sundae
Any three flavors of ice cream filled with soft peanut butter, hot fudge, crunch, chopped Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Or Reese's Pieces and topped with whipped cream and a cherry!
heavenly ash
Heathbar Crunch and Vanilla Ice Cream layered with Marshmallow sauce and Crunchies, topped with whipped cream and a cherry!
Mama k's pb&j
Vanilla Chip and Peanut Butter Oreo Ice cream layered with Raspberry and Peanut Butter sauce, and topped with whipped cream and a cherry!
dirty banana
Banana Oreo and Oreo ice cream layered with hot fudge and slices of banana, topped with whipped cream and a cherry!
long island mudslide
Bailey's and Coffee Ice Cream layered with Hot Fudge and Caramel, topped with whipped cream and a cherry!
dilly, dilly coffee break
Coffee and Dilly Dilly Crumb Ice Cream layered with hot fudge and Crunchies, topped with whipped cream and a cherry!!
alex's candyland
Cotton Candy and Crazy Vanilla Ice Cream layered with Swedish Fish and Gummy Bears OR Sour patch Kids, Rainbow sprinkles and topped with whipped cream and a cherry!
saltay's munchie sundae
Salted Caramel and Vanilla Chip ice cream layered with Caramel, Pretzels, and M&Ms, topped with whipped cream and a cherry!
Long Island Specialty Shakes
Johnny be good!
Strawberry shake topped with a scoop of vanillaice cream, strawberries, whipped cream and a cherry!
angel wings
holy cannoli shake topped with a scoop of holy cannoli, chocolate chips,whipped cream and a cherry!
bobby's girl
vanilla shake with a scoop of chocolate ice cream with chocolate chips, whipped cream and a cherry!
louie louie
a s'mores shake with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, drizzeled with marshmallow sauce, topped with chips, whipped cream and a cherry!